WHAT LIES BENEATH THE CULTURE WARS
“Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.”
— Carl Jung
There never was a Garden of Eden. When archeologist, Steven A. LeBlanc, visited sites all around the world, regardless of time or place, there was always evidence of warfare. He excavated sites in the eastern United States, the Middle East, Peru, and two areas of the American Southwest. Dig after dig he says, “each of these projects yielded evidence of warfare—once I bothered to look for it. Since the beginning of time, humans have been unable to live in ecological balance. No matter where we happen to live on Earth, we eventually outstrip the environment.”
This was counter to the sanitized historical narrative that claimed humans at one point lived in ecological and peaceful balance. Living in harmony with each other and nature was the exception, and warfare was in fact the common norm. He decided that he wasn’t seeing things that didn’t exist; instead his colleagues were ignoring things that did.
As he writes in his book Constant Battles, Why We Fight, “Much of the modern world continues to live more like the tribes and chiefdoms of the past than contemporary city dwellers. And much of the warfare today is more like past-tribe-and chiefdom-level warfare than the high-tech wars of the modern era. Many modern civil wars are actually old tribal wars that never ceased and have just been resurrected in a nation-state context.”
This brings us to our modern day culture wars. The above image is a map of the Online Culture Wars by Disnnovation.Org
The map Online Culture Wars is an overlay of hundreds of politicized memes, along with influential political figures and symbols. It is designed as a discussion starter, intended to visualize and contextualize the ongoing online culture wars, and some of the main political references, actors, and influencers. From Twitter to Facebook, Instagram, Reddit, Gab, or 4chan, one of the by-products of online culture wars is the over-politicization of seemingly mundane topics, products, practices, and cultural elements. In recent years, online cultures have been subjected to a growing polarization, politicization, and radicalization, influenced by numerous actors, and magnified by the very features of ubiquitous social networks. This cartography offers a representation of online ideological and political frictions, integrated into the visual system of a Political Compass meme.
While this map deserves careful study, I’m going to explain why our Culture Wars look the way that they do. Like Steven A. Leblanc, I want to take you to an excavation site that lies beneath the map of the Online Culture Wars. And in the spirit of Carl Jung, explain why the hidden forces of our Culture Wars is our modern mandala (albeit, a very ugly one), which turns like a raging tempest beneath the ocean of our collective consciousness.
Every country has a different culture war. In the United States we are divided on issues like abortion, guns, privacy, drug use, homosexuality, and censorship. While in Canada for instance, they might be more divided on the rights of indigenous peoples, climate policy, language, and pipelines. In Asia and the Middle East, the minefield is concentrated much more in historical narratives, religion, gender, class, and global economics.
It’s quite disorienting to keep track of our culture wars. Especially when and how it manifests online. Culture Wars are defined as a cultural conflict between social groups for moral dominance. Ultimately it’s an infinite war between social groups that determine what is right and wrong in the world. The problem with moral decision making frameworks is that it tends to be binary, reducing everything to good or evil.
Allow me to offer a new way of looking at humanity. In 2018, a little known essay by Duncan A Sabien called How the ‘Magic: The Gathering’ Color Wheel Explains Humanity with the subtext, Move over Myers Brigs, made the rounds on the internet. It’s one of those essays you can’t stop thinking about, and you begin to see everywhere. I’m going to be heavily referencing this essay to explain our Online Culture Wars.
The premise is this. The Magic the Gathering color system does a better job of explaining personalities, organizations, goals, and means than the other popular, but wrong archetypal systems like Enneagrams, MBTI, chakras, or integral theory colors.
By Duncan A Sabien:
Below are the five colors of Magic: white, blue, black, red, and green.
Each color has a central goal, and a default strategy.
White seeks peace, and it tries to achieve that peace through the imposition of order. White believes that the solution to all suffering and unhappiness is coordination and cooperation and rules and restraint. The archetypal white organization would be a church, the United Nations, and a white dystopia would be a fascist regime such as the one in George Orwell’s 1984, or a stagnant society like the one in Lois Lowry’s The Giver.
Central examples of white characters from pop culture include Brienne of Tarth from Game of Thrones, Ozymandias from Watchmen, Superman, McGonagall from Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, and Marge from The Simpsons. In the actual game of Magic, white cards are angels and knights and clerics and loyal steeds, healing spells and protective auras and laws that bind all parties equally, and anthems that strengthen all of your allies at once.
Victory for a white agent feels like brightness, purity, exaltation — a clean breeze sweeping across a high plain under a bright sun. Defeat feels like watching the corrosion creep forward, the great monuments crumble, or the enemy pouring over the gates, knowing that the goodness of the world is unraveling.
Other words associated with white: authority, compassion, community, contribution, fairness, happiness, honesty, justice, kindness, leadership, peace, religion, responsibility, security, service, trustworthiness, altruism, cleanliness, commitment, consistency, duty, conviction, courtesy, dedication, discipline, endurance, gratitude, honor, integrity, patience, poise, respect, teamwork, tradition, unity, valor, honor, formality, generosity, protectiveness, asceticism, authoritarianism, morality, fanaticism, intolerance
– — Openness
A white agent, when presented with a decision or quandary, asks what is the right course of action to take, where “right” depends on their moral or cultural framework.
Blue seeks perfection, and it tries to achieve that perfection through the pursuit of knowledge. Blue believes that things could be almost arbitrarily good if we could all just figure out the truth, and then apply that understanding to its fullest extent. The archetypal blue organization would be a university or a research lab, and a blue dystopia would be one in which efficiency were pursued without morals or limits, or in which intelligence were the sole axis of a meritocracy. Google and Silicon Valley are blue.
Merlin is a classic blue character, as are Spock from Star Trek and Dr. Manhattan from Watchmen. Lisa from The Simpsons is blue, and Ravenclaw House from Harry Potter exists to serve blue students. Harry James Potter-Evans-Verres in HPMOR is more than one color, but his projects with Hermione and Draco are strongly blue-leaning. In MTG, blue cards are wizards and faeries and monsters of the deep, counterspells and illusory tricks, magic that accumulates knowledge and incremental advantage and undercuts, rather than directly opposing (brains over brawn and mind over matter).
Victory for a blue agent feels like clarity, revelation, actualization, conclusion — a final puzzle piece clicking into place, or the last note of a perfect symphonic performance. Defeat feels like everything is slippery, foggy, intractable (and will be evermore), like there’s no path forward and nothing to be done, like all of the potential is wasted and all of the confusion is permanent.
Other words associated with blue: challenge, competence, creativity, curiosity, knowledge, optimism, accuracy, adaptability, awareness, brilliance, cleverness, concentration, development, efficiency, foresight, imagination, insight, logic, quality, rigor, trickery, strategy, service, truth, vision, wonder, perception, nuance, aspiration, focus, invention, patience, wordplay, rationality, subtlety, scholarship, absent-mindedness, cerebral, deception, enigmatic, skepticism, aloofness
A blue agent, when presented with a decision or quandary, asks what course of action makes the most sense, where “sense” is determined by careful thought and the application of knowledge and expertise.
Black seeks satisfaction, and it tries to achieve that satisfaction through ruthlessness. Black wants power and agency so that it can act upon its preferences at any time, reshaping the world around it into whatever it wants. It recognizes no limits upon this pursuit except those which emerge from its own desires and self-interest. It is capable of cooperation and alliance, but only consequentially, as in game theory; at its core, black is amoral, not immoral, since it doesn’t think morality is even really a Thing. The archetypal black organization would be a hedge fund or a startup, and a black dystopia would be a totalitarian dictatorship. Wall Street and BlackRock are markers of black.
In the first Star Wars film, Han Solo was a sympathetic black character, whereas in Game of Thrones Cersei Lannister is a black villain. Every major character in Seinfeld is black except Kramer, and both Bart Simpson and Slytherin House embrace and embody black ideals. Blaise Zabini and Sirius Black are black characters in HPMOR. In the game of Magic, black cards are vampires and necromancers, demons and horrors, kill spells and resurrection spells and sacrificial spells that trade life and creatures for power and pain.
Victory for a black agent feels hefty, exultant, and satisfying, like a bag of gold coins or a heavy hammer — it’s the feeling you have when you know that the game is won, even if you haven’t yet crossed the finish line. Defeat, on the other hand, feels like aging or imprisonment — like scrabbling against an unscalable wall behind which your dreams are turning to ash and trickling away, leaving you with nothing.
Other words associated with black: achievement, autonomy, determination, fame, influence, pleasure, popularity, reputation, success, status, wealth, ambition, control, dignity, excellence, improvement, innovation, liberty, mastery, performance, power, self-reliant, talented, undaunted, decisive, relentless, industrious, persuasive, realistic, suave, competitive, political, proud, solitary, uninhibited, amoral, arrogant, calculating, egocentric, hedonistic, malicious, opportunistic
A black agent, when presented with a decision or quandary, asks what course of action will leave me best off, where “best off” includes having power, influence, safety, and wealth, as well as having moved closer to one’s goals.
Red seeks freedom, and it tries to achieve that freedom through action. Red wants the ability to live in the moment and follow the thread of aliveness and passion. It’s a bit strange to speak of a red “organization,” but to the extent that it’s possible to have an archetypal red organization, it would be one of those art studios that’s owned by no one where there’s paint on every wall and it’s almost impossible to move around what with all of the dancing and debating and half-finished projects. A red dystopia, on the other hand, would simply be anarchy.
Red characters in popular culture include Toph Beifong from Avatar: The Last Airbender, Wile E. Coyote from Looney Toons, both Romeo and Juliet, and Kramer from Seinfeld. Of the Simpsons, Homer is the one who best embodies the spirit of red. In Magic, red cards are goblins and pyromancers and dragons, Lightning Bolts that burn the opponent, illusions that taunt and enrage their allies, spells that grant speed and haste and fragile power, desperate gambles that put everything on the line, and chaotic effects that upset the whole battlefield. You can characterize a lot of content creators as red.
For a red agent, victory feels fiery, beautiful, magnificent, and fierce — it’s the climax of a dance or a brawl or a love affair, the feeling of cresting a summit or having successfully ridden a wave. It’s feeling alive. Defeat for a red agent is correspondingly quiet, empty, and gray — being trapped by things you can’t even pinpoint, to rail against; having nothing to love, nothing to do, nothing to be; feeling nihilism and pointlessness slowly swallowing you whole.
Other words associated with red: authenticity, adventure, beauty, boldness, friendship, fun, humor, loyalty, candor, courage, creation, drive, empathy, enthusiasm, ferocity, independence, individuality, irreverence, joy, originality, passion, purpose, sensitive, spontaneous, trusting, dramatic, flexible, forthright, casual, stubborn, angry, blunt, careless, reckless, destructive, fickle, flamboyant, impulsive, performative, poetic
– — Conscientiousness
A red agent, when presented with a decision or quandary, asks what do I feel like doing?
Green seeks harmony, and it tries to achieve that harmony through acceptance. Green is the color of nature, wisdom, stoicism, taoism, and destiny; it believes that most of the suffering and misfortune in the world comes from attempts to cast off one’s natural mantle, step outside of one’s natural role, or fix things which aren’t broken — it’s the color of Chesterton’s Fence. It seeks to embrace what is — the archetypal green organization would be a hippie commune, or the pop culture interpretation of a Native American tribe (such as in Disney’s Pocahontas), while a green dystopia would be something like the society in Divergent or a tribe with absolutely rigid traditions and an unchanging and unchangeable relationship to its environment.
Green characters are slightly harder to find in the role of the protagonist, but often crop up around the edges of a story. If green had a martial art, it would be aikido — a sort of bending, accepting formlessness backed by subtle power. Both Yoda from Star Wars and Guinan from Star Trek are green, as is Tom Bombadil from Lord of the Rings. Buffy (the vampire slayer) has other colors but moves toward green as she embraces her destiny and, on the more feral side, Wolverine from X-Men often acts from green. The centaur society in HPMOR is green, in that they had sworn not to set themselves against destiny, even if it meant the end of all things. Our last Simpson, Maggie, is green as well, but that’s got more to do with her age than her fundamental character. In the game, green cards are druids and sages, mighty monsters and howling wolves, auras that restore the natural order and regenerate the wounded, and bursts of magic that produce enormous, feral strength or quell entire battles.
Victory for a green agent feels peaceful, fertile, and balanced — a tired general retiring to his farm, a mother nursing her baby, a valley lush with growth now that the rains have come and the pestilence has passed. It’s solemn, but without sadness; joyful, but without ego. Defeat, on the other hand, feels like having no ground beneath your feet, like being cut off from your tribe and family, like watching fair and fragile goodness being crushed underfoot and having everything you thought was true called into question.
Other words associated with green: growth, harmony, respect, spirituality, stability, acceptance, calm, centered, cautious, common sense, contentment, experienced, humility, intuition, maturity, meaning, moderation, restraint, reverence, serenity, sharing, significance, simplicity, strength, vigor, agreeable, contemplative, hearty, barbaric, virile, well-adapted, conservative, traditional, eldritch, ancient
– — Openness
A green agent, when presented with a decision or quandary, asks how are these things usually done? What is the established wisdom?
A world without white is a world of unreliability, with no scaffolds or handrails, no rules or recourse, no sense of fairness and no moral compass. White is the hard and durable skeleton of society, and without it, much of the cooperation and coordination that we rely and depend upon vanishes — even things like driving on a particular side of the road.
A world without blue is a world without curiosity, without investigation, without the nitpicking desire to get every cog into just the right place. More than any other color, blue represents what makes humanity different from other animals, other species — without it, we sink back into the present and lose our bridge to the future.
A world without black is a horror show of codependency, with all the inefficiencies of communist Russia and all of the insipid conformity of the town in Footloose or the society in Equilibrium or the people in the parable of the Emperor’s New Clothes. It’s a place where the sovereignty and nobility of the individual vanishes beneath the weight of the collective — it looks good at first, but without black, you lose the will to empire, the thirst for recognition, the desire to get ahead, the deep and personal wants that define and shape a person’s whole destiny. What’s left is pleasant, but there’s no soul at the core of it — nothing that burns with the hunger for something more.
A world without red lacks a different sort of fire — it’s a world that has wanting, but no passion…only a base and selfish grasping, with no real spark behind it. It’s a world where the rules never change, where the assumptions are never questioned, a world without teenage love and modern art and violent protests and spur-of-the-moment adventures. Without red, everything moves in slow motion and everything has its temperature turned down — like an entire society that’s been sedated.
A world without green, on the other hand, is a world unmoored from reality and disconnected from its own history. It’s a world full of bold schemes that fail to pan out, disasters that take generations to build momentum but are noticed too late. It’s a world where everything is out of place — where nothing truly even has a place — a constant parade of divorces and suicides and famines and extinctions, where things like global warming and eugenics and welfare programs with misaligned incentives happen all the time. It’s a world where the qualities that people derive from Zen Buddhism, or from the contemplation of a sunset, or from a hike in the mountains, or from the embrace of a grandmother, or from the sermon of an ancestor, are all entirely absent. It’s a place where you eat and eat and eat, but you never feel truly full.
In addition to being defined by goals and methods, the five colors also disagree with one another in meaningful ways. There are five central conflicts between colors on opposite sides of the wheel, which help to define them in contrast with one another.
White and black disagree about the relationship between the individual and the group. White prioritizes the group over the individual, and black does the opposite. The phrase “all for one and one for all” is white, whereas the spirit of individual sovereignty expressed in Ayn Rand’s philosophy is black. From white’s perspective, black is selfish and evil; from black’s perspective, white is naive and coercive.
Black and green disagree about the relationship between the individual and the surrounding environment. Green is the color of evolution and thriving, and believes in balance and evolved order, wanting to preserve the existing status quo. Black, on the other hand, sees only unclaimed resources waiting to be exploited. From green’s perspective, black is short-sighted and unbalanced; from black’s perspective, green is stagnant and irresolute. A black agent might try to create a strip mine; a green agent is more likely to build an animal sanctuary.
Green and blue disagree on questions of determinism and free will. Green believes that there is a niche for everyone, and that genetics and environment determine personality and potential. Blue believes in “tabula rasa,” and holds to the claim that anyone can become anything, given the proper nurturing, education, and opportunity. From green’s perspective, blue is hubristic and unwilling to hear the wisdom of the ages; from blue’s perspective, green is complacent and stuck in its ways.
(You may be noticing echoes of criticisms, such as blue and black each harboring similar dissatisfactions with green. This is a feature, not a bug; blue and black are allies and part of that alliance is a shared frustration with their common enemy. More on this below.)
Blue and red disagree about strategy. Blue believes that the best results will be achieved if you think carefully and let reason and logic carry the day, while red believes that it’s too easy to waste time and talk yourself in circles, and that you should instead follow your heart and listen to your gut. Blue sees red as impulsive and rash; red sees blue as repressed and unfeeling and unwilling to act.
Red and white disagree on questions of structure and commitment. Red is episodic, suspicious of rules and order because they constrain one’s ability to grow and change and freely choose. White is more diachronic, interested in finding the small compromises and sacrifices that will allow people to build trust and cooperate reliably. Where red sees cages, white sees scaffolds, and vice versa.
A white/blue agent asks the question how do we know what’s right and good? The whole concept of a “rationality technique” is extremely white/blue — the idea that we might create carefully defined, algorithmic heuristics for doing things better according to some outside standard is not one that other color combinations are likely to produce. Effective Altruism is also a white/blue movement, though it makes efforts to reach out to red (compassion) and black (taking the long view on self-interest).
Blue and black are the enemies of green, which they see as complacent and passive. Blue and black both agree on growth mindset — the idea that one is not defined by one’s origins or constrained to the role society has set. Blue/black characters are often intelligent, clever, arrogant, and aloof — notable examples include Odysseus from The Odyssey, Sherlock Holmes, Lex Luthor, and Quirinus Quirrell from HPMOR.
A blue/black agent asks the question how can I best achieve my goals? It’s fair to describe blue/black as the combination of “enlightened self-interest,” which is why it’s not surprising to find it overrepresented in communities like LessWrong and Silicon Valley, which see themselves as attempting to disrupt the status quo for the better. Transhumanism is a fundamentally blue-black worldview, in opposition to the green imperative to accept death as a crucial and inevitable part of life.
Black and red are the enemies of white, which they see as invasive and tyrannical. Black and red both agree that independence is something to be fostered and defended — red in an attempt to avoid coercion or pressure, and black out of a desire for self-reliance and agency. Many black/red characters lean evil, such as the Joker from Batman and Voldemort from canon Harry Potter, but the combination can also be one of impishness or chaotic selfishness, as with Peter Pan, Deadpool, or Cap’n Jack Sparrow. Achilles from The Iliad is black/red, as is the political persona of Donald Trump and the protagonist of The Fountainhead, Howard Roark.
A black/red agent asks the question how do I get what I want? Because of its dismissive attitude toward judgment and social mores, black/red is often the combination of endorsed hedonism and “live and let live.” The BDSM and kink communities are fundamentally black/red, for example, with many of their norms intended to facilitate the healthy expression of urges and desires that are delegitimized and disincentivized in broader society.
Red and green are the enemies of blue, which they see as icy, disconnected, and cerebral. Red and green both agree on the importance of authenticity — green from a place of wildness and immediacy, and red from a place of passion and self-actualization. Dionysian archetypes are red/green, as is Tinkerbell and the Hulk, and the parts of Wolverine that aren’t green are usually red. On the gentler side of things, Aang from Avatar: The Last Airbender is firmly red/green and is often torn between his innate red playfulness and the gravity and responsibility required of his green role and destiny.
A red/green agent asks the question where am I now, and where should I go? A real-life activity that embodies red/green is Circling (à la the Authentic Relating community), which in part emphasizes setting aside narratives and frames and just being present, in the moment, with yourself and other people.
Green and white are the enemies of black, which they see as selfish, short-sighted, and ultimately self-defeating. They both agree on community — that the whole can be greater than the sum of its parts, and that there are things larger than oneself that are worth sacrificing for. Hufflepuff House from Harry Potter is a green/white institution, and Akela from The Jungle Book is a green/white archetype. Other examples of people and characters in this space include Confucius, Jesus, Rufio from Hook, and Obi-Wan Kenobi (as played by Alec Guinness).
A green/white agent asks the question what’s fair and good? Green/white institutions tend to be centered around compassionate endeavors, but if they go astray it’s in the direction of well-meaning lost purposes and wasted signaling — a lack of blue’s epistemic hygiene — rather than in the direction of cold, heartless efficiency or relentless pursuit of knowledge or the bottom line. They include institutions like the YMCA, Habitat for Humanity, Teach for America, the Lions’ Club, Meals on Wheels, the Boy Scouts and the Girl Scouts, and most small-town churches — basically any organization whose primary purpose is to foster the web of connection between people and to maintain the society’s culture. Some of the institutions above may lean in the direction of red or blue, but they’re primarily green/white.
In addition to serving as a foil for its enemies, each color can also serve as a bridge connecting its two allies. White ties together the orderly tendencies of green and blue, though green and blue disagree on how that order should come to be. Blue believes in careful planning, which both white and black would agree with. Black’s focus on personal agency and personal satisfaction rhymes with blue’s desire for perfection and red’s desire for freedom. Red’s spontaneity lies in a middle ground between green’s wildness and black’s ego-centrism. And green’s serenity ties into the fundamental belief that life is good, which is shared by both red and white.
Although the enemy colors are defined by their disagreement, they can also have a harmony of their own.
The enemy colors white and black combine to form tribalism — the “us versus them” mentality. Think Don Corleone and the other gangsters from The Godfather — a strict system of codes and honor within the group, and almost total impunity with outsiders. Other fictional examples of white/black include the character Rorschach from Watchmen (who would probably also get along with the Punisher) and Magneto from X-Men.
A white/black agent asks the question who’s in my circle of concern? In our own society, the two major political parties have absolutely become white/black in their motivations in recent years, with the most disappointing example being the Republican party’s unwillingness or inability to do anything about the excesses of the president. You can also see the white/black ingroup-outgroup dynamic in certain swaths of social justice culture — there are activists who implicitly hold a scarcity mindset and believe that social progress is largely a zero-sum game, and thus react poorly when other causes threaten to steal the spotlight and siphon off society’s attention, sympathy, and resources.
(Note that “tribalism” is more a thing that can describe the W/B philosophy than the thing. There’s variability in any specific framing of a given color pair. You can treat them as a perfect balance, or as one color tinged by the other, or as something more like “Color A scaffolded with Color B.” Rorschach, for instance, uses black methods to achieve white ends, whereas Machiavelli uses white methods to achieve black ends, and Harvey Dent/Two-Face from Batman simply switches back and forth between all-white and all-black.)
Blue and red taken together are the colors of creativity. Passion combined with perfection, freedom combined with investigation — blue/red is the pairing that most typifies wild artistry and mad science. Although Tony Stark from Iron Man started out blue/black, he ended up blue/red. Willy Wonka is also a blue/red archetype, as are Doc Brown from Back to the Future and Indiana Jones.
A blue/red agent asks the question what can be achieved? What might be possible? The comparison to Tony Stark is maybe starting to wear thin, but in point of fact Elon Musk’s endeavors are one of our strongest examples of blue/red mentality in today’s society. One need only remember how The Boring Company came into existence to see that it’s not only blue’s pursuit of knowledge and perfection that informs Elon Musk’s priorities. While Tesla and Boring and OpenAI certainly reach out to white or black at times, they’re blue/red at their core.
Black and green share a sense of profanity (by which I don’t mean anything to do with foul language, but rather the absence of the sacred and the clean). Black/green is the combination that gets down in the dirt with rot and filth and maggots and worms, the combination that embraces the cycle of life and death and rebirth. It’s Tyler Durden shouting at his minions “You are not special; you are made of the same decaying organic matter as everything else; you are all a part of the same compost heap.” It’s the beautiful products of evolution, and the fact that they clawed their way into existence through a billion generations of suffering and death. It’s necromantic magic and dank, fetid caves and the laughter of mad, inscrutable gods whose wrath and clemency are both beyond the need for justification. It’s being a program that screwed itself into existence running on a computer made of meat. It’s not caring about getting your hands dirty, because there’s literally no other way to get the job done.
A black/green agent asks the question what costs must be paid to achieve the ideal? Notable black/green characters are hard to come by, but they include Lilith, Bagheera from The Jungle Book, and Poison Ivy from Batman. Circe from The Odyssey is black/green, as are the eponymous Shrek and Frankenstein’s Monster. Both the Borg from Star Trek and the zombies of The Walking Dead are black/green antagonists. In our own society, certain branches of ecoterrorists and social justice activists are firmly in this class, and a lot of the actions taken by PETA seem to emerge from black/green motivations.
Meanwhile, red and white are the colors of heroism — of passion channeled through morality, and adherence to laws that may be higher than law. The best of warriors, soldiers, and vigilantes is red/white, as are heroes and martyrs. Examples include Daredevil, Robin Hood, and the Weasley twins from Harry Potter (Gryffindor is a red/white House), as well as V from V for Vendetta and Prince Zuko from Avatar: The Last Airbender (at least, near the end of their arcs).Captain Kirk is red/white where Picard is white/blue, and Albus Dumbledore was red/white in his youth before his war with Grindelwald matured him.
A red/white agent asks the question what needs to be done? What would a good person do? In the 2016 presidential race, Bernie Sanders was attempting to position himself as the red/white candidate in contrast to Clinton’s blue/white and Trump’s red/black, and there are strong red/white motivations in the people who continue to support his platform and push back against the current political status quo.
Lastly, blue/green is the combination of truth seeking. While they disagree strongly about what to do with understanding, both blue and green are deeply committed to seeing and understanding the world as it is, with blue pursuing knowledge and green striving for wisdom. The Litany of Tarski is a central expression of blue philosophy, while the Litany of Gendlin is as green as it gets. Albus Dumbledore was blue/green in his old age, as was Uncle Iroh from Avatar: The Last Airbender. The character Morpheus from The Matrix played a blue/green role in the plot, and the dragon from Grendel was an omniscient blue/green foil for the title character.
A green/blue agent asks the question what do I not yet understand? The two most available and resonant examples of blue/green mentality in our society are genetic engineering, and Gendlin’s Focusing. Genetic engineering is maybe the central case of “see what’s there, so that you can rearrange it to make it better.” And Focusing lies directly between Tarski and Gendlin, as people engage curiously and openly with what they already know and feel beneath the surface.
Just as enemy colors can agree, so too can adjacent, allied colors disagree, usually in ways that involve siding with their other allies. White and blue disagree about individual sovereignty, with white siding with green and blue siding with black. Blue and black disagree about the importance of systems and structures in a way that rhymes with the disagreement between white and red. Black leans more toward trickery and artifice and deception, along with blue, whereas red leans more toward guilelessness and being genuine, along with green. Red and green disagree over roles and destiny, with red wanting to buck the niche that green has ready for it, and green and white disagree over whether order ought be designed or evolved.
Note also that there’s nothing limiting color identities to one or two colors — Captain America, for instance, is (appropriately) red/white/blue, and Dr. Jekyll swaps from blue/red to red/green as he transforms into Mr. Hyde (or possibly blue/black/red to red/black/green).
Often, a person who’s three colors won’t draw evenly from all three — for instance, someone who’s blue-black-red might identify heavily with blue-black’s growth mindset and red’s sense of presence and passion, but not particularly resonate with “creativity” or “independence.” But for the sake of argument, you could imagine a balanced trio as [the sum of its two-color connections] and [the absence of whatever the two remaining colors agree upon].
I myself started as a strong red, then became blue and white over time with a splash of green.
This color wheel system that Duncan articulates allows us to escape the binary classifications of good and evil. Enabling us to think through a full spectrum of how and why people and organizations do what they do.
As Duncan illustrates at the end of his essay you can classify things, and make predictions based on those classifications. For example you use the color system to see if a project has too much of a certain color, why a person is upset, or if two people can get along.
But the main and final point of this essay is that this magic color system maps almost perfectly onto our current reality. I would go even further to say that it is what undergirds today’s culture wars.
Another way to look at this is by asking ourselves, “What are the colors that best represent the times we live in today?” To that, I would say that we live in a time that is dominated by blue and black. Silicon Valley and finance. Social media and our online world is very red.
In a blue and black world, self-interest is what dominates the zeitgeist. This has given rise to the “dark triad” of personality traits.
Traits that are found to be at the center of deception and manipulation to elevate one’s status and gain power. The great paradox and schism our time is that our social crisis will only escalate until morality improves. Yet, the civil war is perpetuated by groups of people with their own "moral agendas" that manipulate people with new propaganda that symbolizes a false morality.
What happens when we live in a society where morality becomes a commodity that becomes exploited? A cult of authenticity is born and it becomes the primary vehicle that drives all moral values.
“The compulsion of authenticity leads to narcissistic introspection, a permanent occupation with one’s own psychology. Communication is also organized psychologically. The society of authenticity is a society of intimacy and exposure. The nudism of the soul into which we are encouraged lends society a pornographic character. Social relations are more genuine and authentic the more intimate they are, the more they reveal what was private.”
We live in a performance society. As the cultural theorist, Byung Chul Han states “All members perform themselves. All produce themselves. Everyone pays homage to the cult of the self, the worship of self in which everyone is his or her own priest.”
When traditional morals are no longer the source of life’s meaning, and sacred symbols no longer describe any sort of underlying reality, what unfolds is a total and complete context collapse. We now live in infinite realities where symbols, old and new can mean anything.
“I have a foreboding of an America in my children's or grandchildren's time -- when the United States is a service and information economy; when nearly all the manufacturing industries have slipped away to other countries; when awesome technological powers are in the hands of a very few, and no one representing the public interest can even grasp the issues; when the people have lost the ability to set their own agendas or knowledgeably question those in authority; when, clutching our crystals and nervously consulting our horoscopes, our critical faculties in decline, unable to distinguish between what feels good and what's true, we slide, almost without noticing, back into superstition and darkness...
The dumbing down of American is most evident in the slow decay of substantive content in the enormously influential media, the 30 second sound bites (now down to 10 seconds or less), lowest common denominator programming, credulous presentations on pseudoscience and superstition, but especially a kind of celebration of ignorance”
— Carl Sagan, The Demon-Haunted World
To thrive in a blue/black world, particularly one that values knowledge, power, and pragmatism, requires a combination of strategic thinking, continuous learning, and individual resilience. Although I am originally red, I developed additional blue, white, and green traits as an intuitive response to living in a blue/black world. I did after all, become a strategist, studied finance, even though I wanted to be an artist.
If we're looking to rebalance a blue/black dominated world, we might want to focus on the colors that could counterbalance these aspects: red, white, and green.
Red: Red stands for emotion, freedom, and individuality. It believes in following one's heart and making decisions based on gut feelings. In a world that's heavily influenced by blue/black, embracing the red perspective can reintroduce passion, empathy, and human connection. Red would advocate for more individual freedom and less manipulation or control.
White: White stands for order, peace, and community. It values fairness, morality, and structured systems. White could counterbalance the individualistic and power-hungry tendencies of a blue/black world by advocating for equality, social responsibility, and ethical behavior. White would push for regulations and institutions that ensure fairness and justice.
Green: Green represents harmony, wisdom, and acceptance. It believes in natural growth and the interconnectedness of all life. Green could provide a counterpoint to blue's drive for constant progress and black's ambition for power, promoting sustainability, balance, and respect for natural systems. Green would stress the importance of living in harmony with our environment and each other, valuing wisdom and understanding over constant advancement or personal gain.
In a practical sense, we could use these colors to guide policy decisions, corporate culture, and individual behavior. For example, introducing more 'green' thinking could involve prioritizing sustainable practices and long-term planning in businesses and government. 'White' could manifest in policies that promote equality and justice, while 'red' could encourage a culture that values individual expression and emotional well-being.
However, it's important to note that this doesn't mean rejecting blue and black entirely. Each color has its strengths and weaknesses, and a balanced society would ideally incorporate the best aspects of each.
I think this is why I've been drawn to the symbol below. The one that I used for my first blog, Reality Marble. I am drawn and driven by the purpose of unity in the age of fragmentation.
Carl Jung said that, "In the products of the unconscious we discover mandala symbols, that is, circular and quaternary figures which express wholeness, and whenever we wish to express wholeness, we employ just such figures.”
Even though Richard Garfield revealed in an interview that the five-color model of Magic: The Gathering was inspired by Master of The Five Magics, this model seems to be embedded in our subconsciousness as it closely resembles ancient asian symbols like that of the I Ching and Korea's cardinal 5 color system, Obangsaek. Somehow, these ancient symbols and their embedded wisdom map accurately to our modern context. What other ancient wisdom lies beneath?